The Best Broadway Shows in New York

Must-see Broadway shows right now

Image of author Maureen
21. October 2019
374 ratings

The answer to whether you should or should not see a Broadway show when visiting New York is crystal clear: YES, it absolutely belongs on your bucket list! What is not always as clear, however, is which show to pick. In order to help you out, we’ve created an overview of the absolute best Broadway shows in NYC right now.

$10 off on purchases over $150 with code AFFLNY10″.
Valid through October 31st. Login required.


Our favorite Broadway shows

It’s tough for us to keep the list of our favorite Broadway shows short, but we’ve finally concluded on our top Broadway shows. We’ve enjoyed some of them so much that we have seen them multiple times! We are confident that, no matter what show you go for, it will be an unforgettable experience!


📍Richard Rodgers Theatre 💲 from 200

best musical in new york

Hamilton holds the record of being the Broadway show with most Tony nominations. It has belonged to the most popular Broadway shows in New York since its opening nights and worldwide. The innovative idea of combining the story of the United States’s founding father Alexander Hamilton with hip hop. Music is incredible and the first of its kind so that even today, all shows are completely sold out. All in all, Hamilton is a true masterpiece by Lin-Manuel Miranda. Learn more…


Dear Evan Hansen

📍Music Box Theatre 💲from 200

best musical on broadwayDear Evan Hansen is hands-down one of the best Broadway shows in New York since its debut. It’s a relatable musical that takes you on an emotional roller coaster ride. While it covers some serious topics, it doesn’t fail to incorporate lots of funny moments that have the whole theater giggle. The music will be stuck in your ears long after you’ve left the Music Box Theatre. Learn more…


Come From Away

📍Schoenfeld Theatre 💲from 200

best broadway shows in new yorkCome From Away truly deserves a spot in our list of best Broadway shows in NYC. The heartfelt musical reminds us of the importance of human kindness. The minimalist stage design helps focus even more on the superb performance of the cast. What else is so special about it? Each of the 12 actors plays 2 different characters. The execution is done in a simple yet extremely clever way. You’ll be surprised! Learn more…

Buy tickets 


📍Walter Kerr Theatre 💲from 200

Best musical on Broadway

When talking about the best Broadway shows in New York, Hadestown cannot be left out. It won the Tony Award for Best Musical 2019. Hadestown retells the Greek myth of Orpheus and Euridice. The tragic love story wins over its audience not only by its stage design but also by the songs. Learn more…

Buy tickets

The best Broadway shows according to critics

Every year, new musicals covet the honor of being recognized as Broadway’s best. The most notable ceremonies praising Broadway shows are the Oscar, Tony and Grammy Awards. These awards, particularly the Tonys, are a great indicator if you are not sure which Broadway shows to watch. Apart from the best musicals below, you’ll find more critics picks (Hamilton, Dear Evan Hansen, and Hadestown) in the other categories.

The Phantom of the Opera

📍Majestic  Theatre 💲from 200

Best Broadway shows of all time

After 30 years on Broadway, the Phantom of the Opera remains one of the best Broadway shows of all time. Even after all this time, the classic musical is seeing sold-out performances on a daily basis. And there is no end in sight. With this level of popularity in mind, it is a must-see Broadway show in New York for everyone. Learn more…

Buy tickets 

The Book of Mormon

📍Eugene O’Neill Theatre 💲from 200

best broadway shows in NYCWith 14 Tony nominations in 2011, the Book of Mormon is still one of the most-nominated musicals of all time. At the evening of the ceremony, it took home 9 Tonys. Critics agreed that musical comedy is one of the best Broadway shows in New York. If you decide to see it, laughs are guaranteed. Learn more…

Buy tickets

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

📍Lyric Theatre 💲from 200
Best Broadway plays

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is the best play on Broadway, making it also one of the best Broadway shows. The special effects in the play are unparalleled and involve not only the stage but the entire theater. Even for non-Harry Potter fans, there is some good news: You don’t necessarily need to be a Harry Potter fan to enjoy the play. What’s unique about this show is that it’s divided into two parts. Learn more…

Buy tickets

The best Broadway shows for kids

Shows are surely one of the most special things to do in New York with kids. When talking about the best Broadway shows in New York for kids, Disney musicals are almost unbeaten. Yet, there are several more shows in NYC beyond Disney musicals that are geared towards children. So here’s a list of kid-friendly shows in New York.

The Lion King

📍Minskoff Theatre 💲from 200

best kids broadway shows

There’s no denying that the Lion King is one of the best Broadway shows, period. However, especially when you are traveling as a family, the Lion King is a great choice because it’s enjoyable for adults and kids alike. It’s bringing to life one of Disney’s most popular movies and truly immerses you into the heartfelt coming-of-age story. Learn more…

Buy tickets


📍New Amsterdam Theatre 💲from 200

aladdin on broadway

Another one of New York’s top Broadway shows is Disney’s Aladdin! With a show like this, you can never go wrong! There is no doubt that your kids will love it, too. The stage design is out of this world, giving you so much to marvel at. Keep an eye out for the magic carpet; visitors are still speculating about how it works. Learn more…

Buy tickets


📍St. James Theatre 💲from 200

best broadway shows for kids

If you are looking for the best kid-friendly Broadway shows right now, you should know that Frozen’s popularity among kids is currently unparalleled. The musical is newer compared to classics like The Lion King and Aladdin and took Broadway by storm upon opening. You’ll be happy walking out of St. James Theatre singing “Let It Go” at the top of your lungs. Learn more…

Buy tickets


📍Gershwin Theatre💲from 200

best broadway shows in nycWicked is a prequel to the story of The Wizard of Oz that tells the story of Elphaba before she became the Wicked Witch of the West. Elphaba and her classmate Glinda are two witches that could not be any more different, yet they develop a profound friendship. The musical Wicked will always be a crowd-favorite and its popular song “Defying Gravity” gives us goosebumps every time. Learn more…


Mean Girls

📍August Wilson Theatre 💲from 200

best teen musicals

The musical Mean Girls is based on the teen movie of the same name. Though you don’t need to know the movie to enjoy the musical, you’d surely appreciate the clever references more if you do. Most high school kids will enjoy the “fetch” Broadway show. It stands out due to its catchy tunes and countless hilarious moments throughout the entire performance. Learn more…

Buy tickets 

What are your must-see Broadway shows 2019 and why? Share your thoughts with us in the comments below!

About the author
Maureen Steinert
Did you like this article?


Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience. You can learn more about it in our privacy policy.

Learn More OK
Log in Register

myNY – your own New York travel planner

Log into myNY and start planning your New York trip. Don’t have an account? Register now - it’s free!

5 reasons why myNY will make creating your itinerary easy!

Reset your password

Please enter your email address to reset your password.

myNY – your own New York travel planner

Register for myNY now and start planning the perfect trip to New York City!