The 18 Best Off-Broadway Shows in New York 2024

Few places can match the vibrancy and allure of New York City, particularly in the realm of Broadway theater. Still, Off-Broadway shows are a staple of the NYC experience, offering a diverse blend of productions that promises something for everyone. So, when in the Big Apple, don’t miss the opportunity to be part of a unique and thrilling performance delivered by some of the most talented artists in the industry!

Your journey into the world of Off-Broadway shows NYC begins here. We’ve got you covered with our comprehensive Off-Broadway Guide, your key to unlocking the best and most captivating theater experiences in the city. Let’s dive right in!

#1 King James

King James Off Broadway PosterWitness the compelling narrative of “King James,” a play by Pulitzer Prize finalist Rajiv Joseph, making its way to the New York City Center from May 2, 2023, to June 18, 2028. Starring Chris Perfetti of “Abbott Elementary” and Glenn Davis, this production goes beyond the court, exploring a friendship forged through a shared admiration for NBA legend LeBron James.

As the men observe LeBron’s ascending career, their bond experiences trials, ruptures, and eventual healing. Following an acclaimed Chicago debut, this off-Broadway production blends sports, camaraderie, and life’s changing dynamics into a captivating spectacle.

Get King James Off Broadway Tickets here

  • When? May 2, 2023 – June 18, 2028
  • Where? New York City Center

#2 The Play That Goes Wrong

The Play That Goes Wrong Off Broadway PosterExperience the merriment of “The Play That Goes Wrong” at New World Stages, from Feb 11, 2019, to Jan 1, 2026. This British comedy, a delightful mix of Monty Python and Sherlock Holmes, promises an unforgettable night filled with uproarious mishaps.

On this amateur troupe’s opening night, props disappear, sets crumble, and lines are forgotten, but that’s just the tip of the iceberg. If you’re looking to laugh, this is one of the funniest off-Broadway shows NYC – so don’t miss it!

Get The Play That Goes Wrong tickets here

  • When? February 11, 2019 – January 1, 2026
  • Where? New World Stages

#3 Blue Man Group

Blue Man Group Off Broadway PosterTake in the timeless spectacle of the “Blue Man Group” at the Astor Place Theatre. This extraordinary ensemble continues to dazzle audiences with their mesmerizing drumming, whimsical humor, and vivid creativity. Speaking volumes without uttering a word, they communicate in the universal tongues of rhythm, comedy, and awe.

Get Blue Man Group Tickets here

  • When? August 17, 1991 –
  • Where? Astor Place Theatre

#4 Titanique

Titanique Off-Broadway PosterEmbark on a theatrical voyage with “Titanique,” playing at the Daryl Roth Theatre from Jun 14, 2022, to Sep 10, 2023. This campy rendition of the iconic James Cameron film, narrated by a Celine Dion impersonator and set to her hit songs, reinvents the tale of Jack and Rose with a pop culture twist.

Though this may not be one of the best off-Broadway shows NYC for kids, it’s a don’t miss on date night or girl’s night!

Get Titanique Off Broadway Tickets here

  • When? June 14, 2022 – September 10, 2023
  • Where? Daryl Roth Theatre

#5 Notre Dame de Paris

Notre Dame de Paris PosterThe international musical sensation “Notre Dame de Paris” returns to New York City this summer to celebrate its 25th Anniversary. Running at the David H. Koch Theater, this production features a 30-member cast and English supertitles. Based on Victor Hugo’s beloved novel, it tells the timeless story of Quasimodo and his devotion to Esmerelda.

Notre Dame de Paris Off Broadway Tickets here

  • When? June 22, 2023 – July 16, 2023
  • Where? David H. Koch Theater (Lincoln Center)

#6 Sleep No More

Sleep No More Off Broadway PosterStep into the captivating universe of “Sleep No More” at The McKittrick Hotel. This immersive rendition of Macbeth takes inspiration from Alfred Hitchcock’s noir aesthetic, creating a uniquely thrilling environment. As you traverse the five floors of the McKittrick Hotel, you’re not just a spectator but an active participant in the unfolding drama.

The beauty of “Sleep No More” lies in its ever-changing narrative; no two visits will ever yield the same experience. This truly is theater reimagined and a must-see for any visitor or off-broadway NYC theater enthusiast.

Get Sleep No More Tickets here

  • When? April 13, 2011 –
  • Where? The McKittrick Hotel

My tip: At the top of the McKittrick Hotel you can find my favorite rooftop bar in the NYC called Gallow Green.

#7 Stranger Sings! The Parody Musical

Catch “Stranger Sings! The Parody Musical” at Playhouse 46 @ St. Luke’s Theatre, a very funny take on the hit Netflix series “Stranger Things.” This musical comedy follows familiar characters on a campy ’80s-inspired, interdimensional journey, complete with singing demogorgons and plenty of stage time for fan-favorite Barb. This imaginative spoof is sure to delight fans of the original series and newcomers alike.

Get Stranger Sings Tickets here

  • When? September 12, 2022 –
  • Where? Astor Place Theatre

#8 The Office! A Musical Parody

The Office Off Broadway PosterJoin the fun of “The Office! A Musical Parody” at The Theater Center. This amusing show condenses the highlights of the beloved sitcom into a two-hour musical spectacle. Experience a typical day at Dunder Mifflin, complete with joke-filled songs and a camera crew capturing the hijinks for a mock documentary.

So, grab your friends and check out one of the most popular off-Broadway shows NYC.

Get The Office Tickets here

  • When? September 20, 2018 – March 12, 2026
  • Where? The Theater Center

#9 Friends! The Musical Parody

Friends Parody Off Broadway PosterFRIENDS! The Musical Parody, an unendorsed comedic musical, humorously satirizes the beloved TV show Friends. It celebrates the escapades of your cherished cluster of young adults as they tackle the challenges of work, life, and romance in 90s Manhattan. The story unfolds in Central Perk, New York’s unique coffee hub, which is abruptly disturbed when a runaway bride unexpectedly appears, throwing the whole group off balance!

This musical rejuvenates favorite scenes from all ten seasons of Friends, delivering them through an unfiltered, brisk, and musical journey. Suitable for viewers 13 years and older, this show is sure to entertain.

Get Tickets here

  • When? March 29, 2022 – December 31, 2023
  • Where? The Theater Center

#10 Little Shop of Horrors

Little Shop of Horrors Off-Broadway PosterWatch the cult classic “Little Shop of Horrors” at the Westside Theatre, where comedy, horror, and camp intertwine in a botanical spectacle. Follow a meek florist as he stumbles upon a carnivorous talking plant, setting him on an unexpected path to success and love.

This acclaimed production, a recipient of multiple Best Musical Revival awards, brings the iconic story to life with a unique off-Broadway twist.

Get Little Shop of Horrors Tickets here

  • When? September 17, 2019 –
  • Where? Westside Theatre

#11 Perfect Crime

The Perfect Crime Off-Broadway PosterStep into the mystery of “Perfect Crime,” one of the best off-Broadway shows NYC has to offer. Playing at The Theater Center, this production holds the distinction of being the longest-running play in New York history, featuring the same leading actress since its opening in 1987.

The suspenseful narrative revolves around a woman suspected of murdering her husband. But did she truly commit the act, or has someone else orchestrated the perfect crime?

Get Perfect Crime Off Broadway Tickets here

  • When? April 18, 1987 – March 12, 2026
  • Where? The Theater Center

#12 Cocktail Magique

The 18 Best Off-Broadway Shows in New York 2024Get ready for a theatrical extravaganza with “Cocktail Magique” at the Cocktail Magique Theatre. Brought to you by the esteemed Company XIV, this immersive production transports audiences to a clandestine world of old-fashioned merriment and intoxicating delights.

This show promises an evening of enchantment and high spirits, making it a must-see for those seeking an unforgettable off-Broadway NYC experience.

Get Cocktail Magique Off Broadway Tickets here

  • When? September 16, 2020 – August 20, 2023
  • Where? Cocktail Magique Theatre

#13 Anthony Rapp’s Without You

Anthony Rapp's Without YouExperience the heartfelt tribute “Anthony Rapp’s Without You” at New World Stages. This intimate musical features Rent star Anthony Rapp as he pays homage to the groundbreaking show that transformed his life.

With renditions of iconic Rent songs and behind-the-scenes anecdotes about its creator, Jonathan Larson, Rapp shares the profound impact Larson had on the entire cast. Don’t miss this unique opportunity to see a piece of Broadway history unfold off-Broadway NYC.

Get Anthony Rapp’s Without You Tickets here

  • When? January 14, 2023 – June 11, 2023
  • Where? New World Stages

#14 Asi Wind’s Inner Circle

Asi Winds Off-Broadway PosterStep into the extraordinary with “David Blaine Presents Asi Wind’s Inner Circle,” an immersive and interactive magic show like no other. This experience invites you into Asi Wind’s mesmerizing world, where the line between spectator and performer blurs. From the moment you enter the theatre, you’re an essential part of the spectacle.

This unique setting amplifies the performance, offering an experience that defies logic and transcends the boundaries of traditional magic. Engage in a thrilling, mysterious, and humorous evening where you don’t just witness magic – you become a part of it.

Get Asi Wind Off Broadway Tickets here

  • When? September 15, 2022 – September 3, 2023
  • Where? The Judson Theatre

#15 La Bohème

La Boheme Off Broadway PosterJoin the Met as it celebrates the 40th anniversary of Franco Zeffirelli’s cherished staging of “La Bohème.” Conducted by Music Director Yannick Nézet-Séguin, this Puccini classic sees Eleonora Buratto and Stephen Costello as the bohemian lovers Mimì and Rodolfo, with Kristina Mkhitaryan and Davide Luciano playing Musetta and Marcello.

Set in post-revolution Paris around 1830, this timeless tale of youthful defiance and love, which inspired the musical ‘Rent,’ continues to captivate audiences since its premiere in Italy in 1896.

Get La Boheme Off Broadway Tickets here

  • When? April 21, 2023 – June 9, 2023
  • Where? Metropolitan Opera House

#16 Leopoldstadt

Leopoldstadt on Broadway Play Poster

Leopoldstadt is a dramatic play that spans from 1899 to the 20th century, set in the Jewish quarter of Vienna. It shows fifty years of time in the life of an extended family over two hours and explores themes like love, beauty, endurance, and family. The inspiration behind the piece comes from the writer’s (Tom Stoppard) own family.

This performance is recommended for ages 10 and up and has no intermission. Leopoldstadt is nominated for the 2023 Tony Awards.

Get Leopoldstadt Off Broadway Tickets here

  • When? October 2, 2022 – July 2, 2023
  • Where? Metropolitan Opera House

#17 Drunk Shakespeare

The 18 Best Off-Broadway Shows in New York 2024Don’t miss the hilarity of “Drunk Shakespeare” at The Ruby Theatre, where the magic of Shakespearean drama and the spontaneity of alcohol-infused performance art collide. In this unique production, five actors, one of whom has had a few too many, strive to present a Shakespearean classic.

As the tipsy actor’s whims dictate the flow, even the Bard’s most tragic tales take on a comedic twist. Encouraging audience participation, spectators are invited to join in the fun and have a drink or two. “Drunk Shakespeare” offers an evening of unpredictable and unforgettable entertainment.

Get Drunk Shakespeare Tickets here

  • When? November 1, 2014 – January 7, 2024
  • Where? The Ruby Theatre

#18 Hell’s Kitchen

Grammy Award-winning artist Alicia Keys and Pulitzer Prize finalist playwright Kristoffer Diaz collaborate on the thrilling coming-of-age musical “Hell’s Kitchen,” set to premiere at The Public this fall.

Featuring music and lyrics by Alicia Keys, “Hell’s Kitchen” draws inspiration from the Grammy-winning singer’s own experiences growing up in the vibrant Manhattan neighborhood. This poignant coming-of-age tale follows Ali as she navigates her journey of self-discovery, seeking her voice and identity in a city that can be both exhilarating and unforgiving. As tensions rise between Ali and her protective mother due to her burgeoning relationship with a drummer, it is through the transformative power of music, reminiscent of the iconic “Fallin’,” that Ali begins to break free.

Get Hell’s Kitchen Off Broadway Tickets here

  • When? Previews October 24, 2023, opening: November 19, 2023
  • Where? Public Theatre NYC


What is considered an Off-Broadway show?

An Off-Broadway show is a professional venue production in New York City that isn’t located within the Broadway Theater District. It typically has a seating capacity between 100 and 499.

What Off-Broadway Shows are good?

Good Off-Broadway shows vary based on personal taste, but popular ones include “Sleep No More,” “Blue Man Group,” and “The Play That Goes Wrong.”

What is Off-Broadway compared to Broadway?

Off-Broadway shows are similar to Broadway shows but are usually smaller in scale, both in terms of venue size and budget. They are often considered more experimental or unconventional.

How does a play go from Off-Broadway to Broadway?

A play goes from Off-Broadway to Broadway typically after a successful run and when producers believe it has commercial viability on a larger scale. It involves increased funding, casting, and production changes to adapt to a bigger venue.

Can Off-Broadway shows win Tonys?

Off-Broadway shows cannot win Tony Awards as these are exclusive to Broadway productions. However, they can win other prestigious awards like the Obie Awards or the New York Drama Critics’ Circle Awards.

Profilbild Steffen Kneist
About the author

I'm a true New York fan! Not only have I visited the city over 25 times but also have I spent several months here at a time. On my blog I show you the best and most beautiful spots of the city, so that you have a really good time! You can also find lots of insider tips in our New York travel guide. Also check out my hotel finder for New York!

Did you like this article?