Our Guide to The 15 Best Thrift Stores in NYC in 2024
New York City is a treasure trove of hidden thrift store gems. Alongside its renowned high-end boutiques and designer showrooms, the city boasts some of the best thrift stores in the country. From retro fashion to discarded couture, each thrift store offers a one-of-a-kind shopping experience that is both sustainable and budget-friendly. So, get ready to explore, discover, and reinvent your wardrobe with our guide to the best thrift stores NYC has to offer.
And after you’ve explored the amazing world of thrifting, make sure to check out our comprehensive NYC Shopping Guide. It features a variety of other shopping experiences the city has to offer.
Without further ado – let’s get started!
Our 15 Favorite Thrift Stores in NYC
-
01
Hamlet’s Vintage
Second Hand Store in Greenwich Village
Founded in 2007, Hamlet’s Vintage began its journey as a humble booth at flea markets and trade shows. Over the years, it has grown and evolved to reign as the largest vintage store in the heart of the Greenwich Village area.
When you step into Hamlet’s Vintage, you’re taking a journey back in time. This beloved thrift store in NYC is a fashion time capsule, offering hand-picked, unique vintage pieces dating from the 1940s through the 1990s. The shop is known for its commitment to quality and authenticity. Hence, every item in the store has been meticulously selected, ensuring that you’re getting an authentic piece of fashion history when you make a purchase.
-
02
Awoke Vintage
Second Hand Store in Greenpoint
From its humble beginnings as a market stall in Perth, Australia, Awoke Vintage has expanded into a renowned destination for thrift shopping in NYC. The store was founded in 2007 by Liz Power, and made a significant move to Brooklyn in 2012. Thanks to the support of her friend, Rachel Despeaux, Liz has expanded Awoke Vintage to three thriving locations, each exuding a welcoming atmosphere that has something for everyone.
When you step into Awoke Vintage, you are immediately surrounded by fabulous items spanning many decades. They offer everything from affordable tubs filled with vintage goodies starting at just $5 and $10 to carefully curated unique pieces. Moreover, they support local Brooklyn-based brands, adding to the eclectic mix. Notably, Awoke Vintage’s expertise lies in vintage denim, helping customers find that perfect pair of jeans. This has attracted a star-studded clientele, including Malia Obama, EmRata, Olivia Rodrigo, and Robert Pattinson, among others.
-
03
Housing Works
Other Shopping in SoHo
Housing Works is a gem among NYC thrift stores. It’s more than just a shop; it’s a mission-driven non-profit committed to making a significant impact. Established to combat HIV/AIDS, homelessness, and the associated stigmas, Housing Works redefines the concept of thrifting by turning your shopping into an act of giving back.
But it gets better! The unique aspect of Housing Works is that 100% of their profits are channeled towards their noble cause. How do they do this? Well, for starters, everything in the store, from books and DVDs to home items, is donated. Then, since the entire operation is run by volunteers, this means every cent from your purchase goes directly to supporting their vital work.
The ever-changing stock of donated items means that every visit to Housing Works is a new adventure. Though you may not always find the specific piece you’re seeking, the thrill of discovery and the knowledge that your money is going to a good cause more than make up for it.
-
04
Tokio 7
Second Hand Store in East Village
Step into the world of Tokio7, a beloved NYC thrift store that has been delighting fashion-savvy shoppers since 1996. Founded by Makoto Watanabe, this consignment store has carved a distinctive niche in the city’s thriving thrift scene.
Shoppers find that Tokio7 is a haven for fashion enthusiasts, offering an impressive range of items. From high-end designer pieces to locally crafted creations, the store boasts a curated selection of apparel, shoes, accessories, bags, and vintage treasures. Luxury brand bags undergo meticulous authentication through either the advanced artificial intelligence system, Entrupy, or the expertise of the knowledgeable staff.
With a deep appreciation for its Japanese heritage, Tokio7 introduces customers to a diverse roster of designers from Japan. This cultural richness combined with an expansive product range, makes Tokio7 one of the best thrift stores in NYC.
-
05
Beacon’s Closet
Second Hand Store in Midtown Manhattan
Beacon’s Closet, a beloved fixture of the NYC thrift store scene, has deep roots in Brooklyn. This locally owned and female-founded establishment is renowned for its unwavering commitment to sustainability and ethical business practices.
Beyond its ethical foundation, Beacon’s Closet is celebrated for its expansive and ever-evolving inventory. The store’s commitment to quality and variety has earned it a place among the top 10 second-hand stores in NYC, garnering significant praise from local and international media.
In fact, Beacon’s Closet has caught the eye of the fashion world, receiving accolades from respected publications like Goop, Thrillist, Buzzfeed, Vanity Fair, The New York Times, and even Italian and French Vogue. The store’s reputation precedes it, captivating fashion enthusiasts far and wide.
-
06
Wonders of Walter
Second Hand Store in Williamsburg
Nestled in the vibrant neighborhood of Williamsburg, Wonders of Walter is a hidden gem among NYC thrift stores. What sets this store apart is its unique setting—a garage-turned-shopping haven, of course, only when the weather permits. This unconventional atmosphere adds to the eclectic charm that defines Wonders of Walter.
So, the next time you’re looking for an authentic thrift shop in NYC, step inside and prepare to be awestruck by the selection of vintage delights. Walter’s carefully curated collection caters to every thrift enthusiast’s imagination. From timeless designer pieces that evoke the spirit of bygone eras to well-worn t-shirts and denim with their own stories to tell, the inventory at Wonders of Walter is a testament to the saying that ‘fashion never truly goes out of style.’
-
07
Mr. Throwback
Second Hand Store in East Village
Looking for an unforgettable journey back in time? Then Mr. Throwback, one of the most intriguing thrift stores in NYC, is your go-to destination. Nestled in New York’s East Village, Mr. Throwback has been serving up a slice of the 1980s and ‘90s since its inception in 2012.
Specializing in original vintage sports apparel like 90s Starter jackets, NBA Champion jerseys, Chalk Line jackets, and snapbacks, Mr. Throwback is a paradise for retro sports enthusiasts. Sneakerheads are not left out either, with a well-curated collection of classic kicks. Not to mention their very own brand which includes officially licensed collaborations with Chalk Line, SLAM Magazine, and Starter. So, get ready to step into this East Village gem and uncover the best of 80s and 90s fashion.
-
08
Country of
Second Hand Store in Chinatown
Embodying the personal style of owner Jonah Brown, Country Of is a testament to exceptional taste and curated quality, making it one of the best thrift stores in NYC. Originating as a vendor at the Hester Street Fair in the Lower East Side, Country Of has since grown into a beloved establishment among vintage fashion enthusiasts.
Upon entering the shop, you’ll be greeted by an impressive array of hand-selected unique pieces, all of which are American-made. But the collection doesn’t stop at the U.S. borders. Country Of also boasts an exquisite selection of Japanese and European designer pieces. As you browse the neatly arranged racks, expect to see well-known brands such as Levi’s, Comme des Garçons, and Jean Paul Gaultier.
So, if you’re a fan of high-quality vintage and international designer apparel, make sure to add Country Of to your list of thrift stores to explore in NYC. It’s a shopping experience that offers a remarkable blend of American vintage and international fashion flair.
-
09
AuH20
Other Shopping in East Village
If you’re making a list of the best thrift stores in NYC to visit, AUH2O is a name that should definitely be on your radar. This friendly and welcoming thrift store has a reputation for housing a fabulous selection of affordable, high-quality items that are sure to spark joy in any thrifting enthusiast’s heart.
At AUH2O, you’ll discover an eclectic mix of stylish pieces that cater to a range of tastes. Whether you’re hunting for a unique vintage accessory to complete your outfit or a contemporary piece to refresh your wardrobe, this charming NYC thrift store has something to offer.
-
10
The Thrifty HoG
Second Hand Store in Flatiron District
Next, be sure to check out The Thrifty HoG, an upscale resale boutique that adds a philanthropic twist to the NYC thrift store scene. Opening its doors in May 2010, this boutique is not just a store, but a mission in action. Each purchase you make here directly contributes to a noble cause which is supporting homeless mothers and their children.
This store boasts a carefully curated selection of new, gently used, and vintage clothing and accessories for both men and women. Additionally, you’ll find a variety of small decor items, artwork, and home furnishings. The best part? All items are 100% donated.
But the store’s impact goes beyond simply selling goods. It also provides ‘Hearts of Gold’s’ moms with job training skills and pays them a living wage, helping them take a step towards self-sufficiency. Every dollar made from your purchases at The Thrifty HoG goes straight into funding ‘Hearts of Gold’s’ programs and services.
So next time you’re thrifting, why not make it count in more ways than one? Visit The Thrifty HoG, discover an array of chic finds, and help make a difference in someone else’s life!
-
11
Buffalo Exchange
Second Hand Store in Boerum Hill
If you’re on the hunt for thrift stores in NYC that offer a wide selection and an ever-changing inventory, Buffalo Exchange should be on your must-visit list. Founded in 1974, this beloved thrift store has been making waves in the second-hand market for decades, offering shoppers an extensive range of stylish, affordable, and unique finds.
Buffalo Exchange operates on a simple yet effective model — buy, sell, and trade. This means you can not only pick up an array of fashionable items but also sell your preloved clothes for cash or store credit. From vintage gems to recent designer labels and everything in between, this store’s inventory is as diverse as the city it calls home.
-
12
Cure Thrift Shop
Other Shopping in East Village
Cure Thrift is one of the best thrift stores in NYC, where every purchase helps contribute to a noble cause. Situated in Manhattan’s vibrant East Village, this non-profit thrift destination dedicates all its proceeds to juvenile diabetes research and advocacy.
Established in 2008 by Liz Wolff, a fourth-generation New Yorker diagnosed with type 1 diabetes at the age of 11, Cure Thrift is a delightful blend of her passion for arts, antiques, and her personal mission to help find a cure for type 1 diabetes. Under her guidance and a dream team of artists and designers, the store has blossomed into an enchanting thrifting experience, often hailed as the most magical thrift shop in Manhattan.
-
13
City Opera Thrift Shop
Other Shopping in Chelsea
When you’re exploring NYC thrift stores, there’s one you simply can’t miss: City Opera Thrift Store. This gem of a shop is as distinct as its name suggests, standing as the only philanthropic thrift store in New York City dedicated to supporting the arts. Yes, you heard that correctly! The revenue from your purchases helps fund the exciting performances and educational programs of the New York City Opera.
As you wander through the store, you’ll find well-curated, high-quality vintage items, designer clothing, and unique home goods, all at bargain prices. Their diverse and ever-changing inventory ensures you’re always in for a surprise.
-
14
Screaming Mimis
Second Hand Store in West Village
Experience a shopping journey that transcends the ordinary at Screaming Mimi’s. This extraordinary NYC thrift store that has revolutionized the vintage clothing scene. Since its inception, Screaming Mimi’s has approached vintage clothing and costumes with a keen stylist’s eye, setting it apart from the rest.
But Screaming Mimi’s is more than just a store; it’s an adventure waiting to unfold. Vibrant displays, knowledgeable staff, and even celebrity shoppers contribute to an atmosphere that is lively and unforgettable. However, the true star of the show is the clothing itself. With a constant quest for exceptional and one-of-a-kind pieces, each visit to Screaming Mimi’s transforms into an exhilarating treasure hunt.
-
15
The Vintage Twin
Other Shopping in Little Italy
As we conclude our tour of the best thrift stores in NYC, there’s one final must-see destination: The Vintage Twin. Situated in the vibrant heart of SoHo, this store stands out with its eclectic and trendy collection. In fact, even supermodels like Gigi Hadid and Taylor Hill have been spotted exploring its aisles, further adding to its allure.
Embodying the paradoxical mantra, “the future is vintage,” The Vintage Twin perfectly captures the city’s renewed fascination with vintage styles. However, it’s important to note that popularity often comes with a higher price tag. While some of their hand-picked, unique pieces might be pricier than your typical thrift store finds, for those who appreciate originality and a touch of nostalgic chic, investing in The Vintage Twin is a worthwhile indulgence!
Frequently Asked Questions
How do thrift stores work?
Thrift stores primarily sell used goods such as clothing, furniture, and household items that are donated by individuals. Once donated, the items are sorted, cleaned, priced, and displayed for sale. The funds generated from the sales usually support charitable causes or non-profit organizations. Some thrift stores even provide employment and training opportunities to underprivileged communities.
Are there thrift stores in New York?
Yes, there is a thriving culture of thrift stores in New York. The city is known for its diverse range of thrift shops, each offering its unique inventory of goods. From upscale consignment boutiques to vintage clothing outlets and affordable thrift shops, New York has it all.
What are the best thrift stores in NYC?
There are many outstanding thrift stores in NYC, each with its distinct character and merchandise. The list includes but is not limited to Hamlet’s Vintage, Awoke Vintage and Housing Works. These stores offer a mix of vintage clothing, designer pieces, furniture, books, and more.
What are the most reasonably priced junk and thrift stores in NYC?
New York City offers a variety of thrift stores that cater to different budgets. For reasonably priced items, Awoke Vintage and Housing Works provide excellent value with their affordable collections. Other thrift stores like Tokio7 and The Thrifty Hog also offer a selection of reasonably priced items.
What is the best thrift store in Manhattan, NYC?
The ‘best’ thrift store can be subjective as it often depends on what you’re searching for. However, stores like Housing Works, Beacon’s Closet, and Cure Thrift are frequently cited for their quality and diverse offerings, making them excellent starting points for your thrifting journey in Manhattan.
Do the thrift stores in NYC sell good stuff?
Absolutely! The thrift stores in NYC are known for the quality and variety of their merchandise. From vintage designer clothing to unique home décor pieces, high-quality books, vinyl records, and more, there’s something for everyone. Keep in mind that the inventory in thrift stores changes regularly, making each visit a unique experience.
What are vintage, cheap or thrift stores in NYC that you have seen have a lot of leather clothes or shoes for women?
If you’re in search of leather goods, The Vintage Twin and Mr. Throwback are excellent options. They often stock a variety of vintage and contemporary leather clothes and shoes. But remember, thrift store inventories change frequently, so it’s always a good idea to visit often or get in touch with the stores to check their latest collections.
You'll also love this:
