The Best Broadway Shows during the Holiday Season in NYC (2024)

The holiday season in New York City is nothing short of magical. As snowflakes gently kiss the bustling streets, tourists and locals alike are on the lookout for festive events to make their season brighter. And what better way to immerse oneself in the city’s enchanting festive ambiance than by catching some of the best Broadway shows during the holiday season in NYC?

It’s the perfect prelude to experiencing Christmas in NYC or rounding off a heartwarming Thanksgiving in NYC. That said, if you’re a Broadway aficionado or just someone seeking holiday cheer, this guide is your ticket to an unforgettable season. 

Broadway Shows during the Holiday Season in NYC

  1. 01

    Cirque du Soleil: 'Twas the Night Before … (December 7 - 28, 2023)

    Broadway Show in Midtown Manhattan
    Add to myNY added

    Let the enchantment of the holidays sweep you off your feet at The Theater At Madison Square Garden. Here, Cirque du Soleil breathes a delightful twist into the timeless Christmas tale with ‘Twas the Night Before…’. Diving deep into the heart of Clement Clarke Moore’s iconic poem, “A Visit from Saint Nicolas,” the story unfolds around a young girl’s journey to rediscover the wonder of the season.

    Brace yourself for an avalanche of awe as gravity-defying acrobatics meld with heartwarming melodies of the season, all reimagined by the Cirque magicians. Spearheaded by James Hadley, a Cirque du Soleil Senior Artistic Director with 25 years in the theatrical realm, this is the festive feast your family has been waiting for.

  2. 02

    Moulin Rouge

    Broadway Show in Theatre District
    moulin_rouge_broadway_190709124154005_1600x800
    Add to myNY added

    Experience the enchantment of Parisian nights at the Al Hirschfeld Theatre with Moulin Rouge! The Musical. This show invites you into a world brimming with vivid colors, opulence, and the free-spirited essence of bohemia. At the center of this dreamlike tapestry is Christian, a sincere writer whose heart beats only for the radiant Satine. Their love story, as brilliant as it is ill-fated, teeters on the edge of a knife, with the opulent Duke of Monroth lurking in the shadows, convinced that love comes at a price.

    As the backdrop, a symphony of modern hits spanning five decades surrounds the audience, perfectly complementing the awe-inspiring sets and mesmerizing dance performances. With John Logan’s expert storytelling, visionary direction by Alex Timbers, and Sonya Tayeh’s electrifying choreography, prepare yourself for a theatrical experience that will dazzle your senses and captivate your heart.

  3. 03

    The Lion King

    Broadway Show in Midtown Manhattan
    Our Highlight
    10431464_709246455830523_214457459437786949_n
    Add to myNY added

    Journey to the heart of the Pride Lands and experience a musical odyssey unlike any other at Minskoff Theatre. The Lion King immerses you into a world where the plains of Africa come alive with artistry, music, and emotion. This multi-award-winning spectacle, adorned with six Tony Awards, including Best Musical, unravels a tale of hope, legacy, and adventure that has touched souls globally.

    Crafted by the musical maestros Elton John and Tim Rice, with Julie Taymor’s visionary direction and Garth Fagan’s captivating choreography, every moment is pure theatrical magic. Running for a wholesome 2 hours and 30 minutes, it’s an ageless adventure suitable for guests aged 6 and up. But remember, to ensure everyone’s enjoyment, Disney has certain age and ticket policies in place.

  4. 04

    Radio City Christmas Spectacular

    Broadway Show in Midtown Manhattan
    radio_city_christmas_spectacular_161104104936001
    Add to myNY added

    Step into a winter wonderland as you enter Radio City Music Hall, fondly dubbed the “Showplace of the Nation.” Here, the world-renowned Rockettes grace the stage, dazzling audiences with their signature eye-high kicks. Dive into timeless classics like the mesmerizing “Parade of the Wooden Soldiers” and the awe-inspiring “Living Nativity.”

    But it’s not just about the dance; Santa dashes straight from the North Pole for a cameo, and an exhilarating 3-D film catapults you on a magical sleigh ride through New York’s snowy streets. Year after year, families are pulled back to this iconic venue, seeking that heartwarming holiday thrill.

  5. 05

    Agatha Christie's The Mousetrap

    Broadway Play in Theatre District
    Add to myNY added

    After seven decades of anticipation, Agatha Christie’s world-famous mystery, THE MOUSETRAP, is finally making its debut on Broadway. And as the planet’s longest-running play, its gripping allure remains as potent as ever. To infuse a genuine touch of old-world charm, the Broadway premiere will incorporate elements from the original 1952 London production, including the timeless mantelpiece clock and a unique backstage wind machine.

    While this show carries the unmistakable essence of London’s theater district, the ensemble of Broadway actors promises to inject new vitality into this timeless whodunit. Don’t miss your chance to watch this mystery unfold. After all, it’s held audiences spellbound for an astonishing 70 years! Knowing that we can confidently say this is one of the best Broadway shows during the holiday season in NYC 2023.

  6. 06

    New York City Ballet: George Balanchine's The Nutcracker

    Other Events in Upper East Side
    The Nutcracker
    Indiana Woodward and Company in George Balanchine’s The Nutcracker. Photo credit: Erin Baiano
    Add to myNY added

    Experience a dreamlike journey with the New York City Ballet as they present George Balanchine’s magical rendition of The Nutcracker. Float in Tchaikovsky’s eternal melodies, drifting from snowy battlegrounds with playful mice and toy soldiers to the enchanting Land of Sweets. Witness theatrical marvels from a growing Christmas tree that astounds at 40 feet to the gentle drift of crystal-shaped snowflakes.

    But the ballet’s splendor isn’t just in its set; it’s in the dance. From the whimsical Snowflake Waltz to the entrancing Kingdom of the Sugarplum Fairy, every movement is a spectacle. Over 140 performers, including 90 dancers and student casts from the School of American Ballet, unite to craft this monumental holiday masterpiece, proving that the realm of fantasy knows no bounds.

  7. 07

    Merrily We Roll Along

    Broadway Show in Theatre District
    230531074046001
    Add to myNY added

    Rejoice, Stephen Sondheim fans! Coming to Broadway in Fall 2023 is Merrily We Roll Along, bringing together the talents of Jonathan Groff, Lindsay Mendez, and Daniel Radcliffe. As you dive into this musical, you’ll traverse through a tapestry of three tumultuous decades in the entertainment world. Along the way, you’ll be drawn into the intricate dynamics between composer Franklin Shepard and his two lifelong confidants: the insightful writer Mary and the passionate lyricist Charley.

    Featuring some of Sondheim’s most unforgettable songs, the musical initially took the stage under Maria Friedman’s direction at London’s Menier Chocolate Factory. From there, it seamlessly transitioned to the Harold Pinter Theatre, where, amidst a wave of glowing reviews, it notably secured the Olivier Award for Best Musical. Trust us! This is a Broadway show you don’t want to miss!

  8. 08

    Aladdin

    Broadway Show in Midtown Manhattan
    Aladdin is among the Longest Running Broadway shows in NYC
    Add to myNY added

    In a blend of magic, mischief, and dreams, Disney’s Aladdin makes its majestic debut on Broadway, turning the cherished movie into a theatrical marvel. Designed with precision and flair by Disney’s renowned Imagineers, both the set designs and costumes come together in a grand display.

    As you rub the iconic lamp, Aladdin, along with the audience, begins a captivating journey filled with wonder. While you’ll be taken back by the nostalgic melodies from the award-winning film, you’ll also be introduced to new tunes specifically composed for this stage adaptation. Thus, a magical world unfolds before you, ensuring an evening of pure enchantment.

  9. 09

    A Beautiful Noise, The Neil Diamond Musical

    Broadway Show in Theatre District
    230531113845001
    Add to myNY added

    Venture into the mesmerizing universe of the legendary Neil Diamond through A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical. As you traverse this melodious expedition, classics such as “Sweet Caroline” and “Cracklin’ Rosie” will serenade you.

    Orchestrated under the masterful direction of Tony Award winner Michael Mayer and enhanced by the intricate choreography of Steven Hoggett, each scene resonates deeply with Neil Diamond’s legacy. With the story brilliantly crafted by the four-time Academy Award nominee Anthony McCarten, audiences are bound to leave Broadhurst Theatre with the heartfelt sentiment, “Good times never seemed so good,” lingering in their minds.

  10. 10

    & Juliet

    Broadway Show in Theatre District
    230601095218001
    Add to myNY added

    Delving deep into Shakespeare’s world, & Juliet stands out as one of the best Broadway shows during the holiday season in NYC. This refreshing take on the aftermath of Romeo’s departure prompts a question: Can Juliet, the damsel of Verona, pen a new chapter for herself?

    While she whirls in dance, letting go of past heartaches and embracing the momentary bliss of night, a profound realization dawns upon her. To move forward, she must reconcile with her past. Is there truly a purpose beyond Romeo, or is their love story too gripping to forget? Embark on this revamped narrative this holiday season and witness Juliet’s compelling voyage toward self-awareness.

  11. 11

    Some Like It Hot - CLOSED

    Broadway Show in Theatre District
    230601073314001
    Add to myNY added

    In a vibrant display of theatrical energy, “Some Like It Hot” transforms a cherished Hollywood comedy into an exhilarating musical spectacle. Watch as two friends deftly navigate peril and, in their escapade, unexpectedly tumble into the arms of love.

    With the combined brilliance of Marc Shaiman, Scott Wittman, Matthew López, and Amber Ruffin, and underscored by Casey Nicholaw’s choreographic magic, this show offers a captivating blend of romance, humor, and sheer mischief. Prepare for a heartwarming whirlwind that promises both sizzle and laughs.

  12. 12

    Blue Man Group

    Broadway Show in NoHo
    musicals_header_blue_man_group
    Add to myNY added

    As it stands, the Blue Man Group isn’t easy to categorize. It’s a fusion of theater, rhythm, art, and comedy, creating a distinct spectacle that’s both immersive and engaging. Back in the ’80s, when Chris Wink, Phil Stanton, and Matt Goldman first unveiled their inventive blue-faced performances, few could have predicted the global phenomenon it would become.

    Over the years, while the core of the show has remained true to its roots, it’s continuously reinvented itself, ensuring that audiences always have something fresh to look forward to. Through a seamless blend of electrifying music, interactive comedy, and a dash of vaudeville, this show offers an experience that’s truly unparalleled. So, as you settle into this holiday season, be ready for the unexpected twists and turns that only the enigmatic Blue Men can deliver.

  13. 13

    Chicago

    Broadway Show in Midtown Manhattan
    Our Highlight
    chicago_musical_nyc_headout_2_1600x960_1600x800
    Add to myNY added

    As the holiday season in NYC sets in, Broadway comes alive with some of its finest offerings. Among the best Broadway shows during the holiday season in NYC is Chicago, which is celebrating its 25th anniversary. This timeless tale, brimming with ambition, deception, and allure, delves deep into the shadows of fame and fortune.

    With its tales of murder, greed, and treachery, coupled with sensational dancing and iconic songs, it’s no wonder the show has clinched 6 Tony Awards and a Grammy. So, whether it’s your first time or a nostalgic revisit, Chicago’s allure remains irresistible. And after a quarter of a century, it’s clear why the name on everyone’s lips is still… CHICAGO.

  14. 14

    Sweeney Todd

    Broadway Show in Theatre District
    Add to myNY added

    Melding a chilling narrative of revenge and savagery, Sweeney Todd makes a dramatic return to Broadway, this time under the masterful guidance of Tony Award winner Thomas Kail. As we dive into Stephen Sondheim and Hugh Wheeler’s haunting tale, we witness the sinister journey of a barber spiraling into madness and, along the way, his unsettling alliance with the pie shop owner, Mrs. Lovett.

    What makes this rendition stand apart is its homage to the past, specifically reviving Jonathan Tunick’s classic orchestration from its 1980 debut. Moreover, with the spotlight shining on the multitalented Josh Groban coupled with the brilliance of Tony winner Annaleigh Ashford, the stage is set for an evening brimming with compelling narratives and unparalleled musical finesse.

  15. 15

    Harry Potter and The Cursed Child

    Broadway Play in Theatre District
    190130105941011
    Add to myNY added

    Harry Potter and the Cursed Child stands as a jewel among the best Broadway shows during the holiday season in NYC. This reimagined spectacle unfolds over an engaging 3.5 hours, introducing us to an older Harry and his young son, Albus. Together, they wrestle with the heavy shadows of their family’s past while facing an uncertain future.

    As a continuation of J.K. Rowling’s esteemed wizarding world, this production dives deep into the themes of legacy, hidden dangers, and the enduring bond of family. So, as the season’s festivities begin, prepare to be captivated once more by the enchantments and intricacies of the Potter universe.

Profilbild Steffen Kneist
About the author

I'm a true New York fan! Not only have I visited the city over 25 times but also have I spent several months here at a time. On my blog I show you the best and most beautiful spots of the city, so that you have a really good time! You can also find lots of insider tips in our New York travel guide. Also check out my hotel finder for New York!

Did you like this article?