Bleecker Street is one of the most famous streets in New York City, and for a good reason. Located in the heart of Greenwich Village, this spot is famous for restaurants, clubs, bars, and pubs. So, when it comes to having a good time, there’s no way not to consider heading down to Bleecker Street. But, how do you go about choosing the best pizza in the area?
You'll also love this:
It’s no secret that New York City is known for its pizza. From the classic thin crust to extra-long slices, NYC has so many options that it can be hard to choose just one. While you can find pizza on almost every corner, some spots are better than others.
Luckily for you, we’ve done the work and ranked our favorites, so you’ll never have to go without a good slice of pizza on Bleecker Street! In this article, we’ll cover the TOP 14 Bleecker Street pizza spots you should consider for your next slice.
Here You Can Get the Best Pizza along Bleecker Street NYC
These are the best pizza spots for us on Bleecker Street and adjacent streets:
Bleecker Street PizzaPizza Spot in West VillageAdd to myNY added
There’s no way to talk about the best Bleeker Street pizza joints without mentioning Bleeker Street Pizza itself. Consistently named as the best pizza in NYC by Food Network for three years in a row, it’s no wonder that this place always has a line wrapped around the door. The pizza here is classic New York style with a thin and crispy crust loaded with cheese and your choice of toppings.
What makes this place unique from the others is the recipe they use for their pizza. Bleeker Street Pizza was initially opened in 2004 using an old family recipe to create what is known as the “Nonna Marie Pie.”
While they have tons more flavors to choose from today at an affordable price, the best types to try are the Nonna Maria Pizza and Grandma Pizza. But, of course, you can’t go wrong with a traditional pepperoni pizza slice either.
John's of Bleecker St.Pizza Spot in West VillageAdd to myNY added
John’s of Bleecker Street was initially opened in 1929 on Sullivan Street by immigrant Giovanni Sasso from Naples, Italy, before it moved to its current location along Bleecker Street. Since then, this spot has been a go-to for many who are looking for some of the best pizza in NYC.
John’s uses coal-fired brick ovens to cook their pies, giving each slice a unique texture and taste that you won’t find elsewhere. Their traditional New York-style pizzas use fresh ingredients, including homemade sauce made from Italian plum tomatoes, mozzarella cheese layered with fennel sausage or pepperoni if you’re feeling extra hungry! While they have tons more options than just classic square slices here, there is nothing better than trying out one of their plain old pepperoni slices if you want something simple yet delicious.
Enjoy their classic Sasso Pies, which includes aged mozzarella and tomato sauce, or their famous John’s Bianca, which has aged mozzarella, ricotta, garlic, basil, and no sauce in one of their old-style original wooden booths with an art deco design.
Joe's PizzaPizza Spot in West VillageAdd to myNY added
Joe’s Pizza is another one of the OG’s when it comes to pizza on Bleecker Street. This spot has been around since 1975, created initially by Pino Pozzuoli, who immigrated from Naples, Italy. Joe’s Pizza is known for having some of the best traditional New York pizza slices in town.
People love Joe’s Pizza because of the consistency and the dedication. They still use the same original recipe from 1975, and it’s still an independently owned business, still supervised by Joe, the founder. So you won’t find any fancy concoctions or slices here. Instead, you’ll find delicious, fresh, New York-style pizza.
While you can order extra toppings and different specialty pies if you call and request it, the best way to experience Joe’s is by trying one of their cheese, mozzarella, or Sicilian square slices. They also offer fresh salads served family-style upon request if you’re feeling extra hungry!
Pizza Loves Emily: West VillagePizza Spot in West VillageAdd to myNY added
Pizza Loves Emily is another one of the most popular spots in NYC for pizza on Bleecker Street. Created by a couple who fell in love over a slice of pizza, Emily and Matt, this spot is perfect if you’re looking to sit down, relax with friends or family over a slice, and have some drinks. Plus, their beautiful outdoor area is even dog friendly so bring Fido along with you while enjoying your pie outside.
That makes Pizza Loves Emily unique are all of the options available when it comes to toppings and the unique combination of specialty pizzas. You must try the Emmy Burger Pizza made with LaFrieda beef, Emmy sauce, caramelized onion, American cheese, and pickles, or the Arenstein made with pepperoni, pickled chili, and honey.
If you’re not in the mood for pizza, you can choose from tons of other high-quality menu options sure to satisfy your taste buds, like their crispy chicken sandwich or the truffle mac and cheese. But, of course, you can’t go wrong with a classic Margherita pizza if you’re looking for something simple but delicious.
Carroll PlaceItalian Restaurant in Greenwich VillageOur HighlightAdd to myNY added
Carroll Place on Bleecker Street has an exciting concept, as it’s both a gastropub and wine bar where you can enjoy Italian-inspired food. It’s one of our favorite spots when we go for brunch in New York. The atmosphere is relaxed, the vibe is always good and the food is delicious!
Our favorites have been the pizza with truffles and the Pasta Vongole. The fact that the pizza oven is wood fired gives the pizzas a taste like a pizza should have! By the way, next time try the Carroll Place Burger with Gorgonzola. This one looked mega delicious too!
My tip: if you want to go for brunch, be sure to reserve a table in advance!
99 Cent Village PizzaPizza Spot in West VillageAdd to myNY added
If you’re looking for a really cheap and quick slice of pizza, 99 Cent Village Pizza is the spot for you. This no-frills pizzeria offers some of the cheapest slices in all of NYC, but don’t let that deter you from their delicious pies. Although they may not have a website, it’s worth stopping by to pick up a few slices on your way home or during a lunch break. If you’re short on time, you can still place an online order with your local delivery apps.
What makes 99 Cent Village Pizza so great are their classic New York-style slices. While they only offer basic pizza varieties, such as cheese, pepperoni, sausage, and veggie pizza, they are always fresh and made with high-quality ingredients. Plus, at only $0.99 for regular cheese slices, it’s hard to beat the price!
If you’re looking for something a little more filling, try their Sicilian slices, which are thicker and come with sauce on the side. You can also add toppings for an extra charge, but even without them, these slices are mouth-watering and definitely hit the spot.
Village Square PizzaPizza Spot in West VillageAdd to myNY added
Taking a classic spin on pizza, Village Square Pizza offers a unique and delicious menu sure to please everyone. With options like their buffalo chicken pizza or the eggplant square pizza, you’re sure to find something for even the pickiest of eaters. Of course, if you’re not looking for a unique slice, you can always choose the classic, made with family recipe tomato sauce, extra virgin olive oil, grated parmesan, and whole milk mozzarella.
What makes this spot so great is that it’s perfect for groups – whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just catching up with friends. They offer large pizzas in both classic and specialty varieties, as well as garlic knots and calzones. Regardless of what you choose, their pizza slices make it easy and affordable to enjoy a night out at Village Square Pizza.
If you can’t make it to the restaurant, no problem! You can place an online order with your local delivery apps, so you never have to miss out on Village Square Pizza again.
Two Boots West VillagePizza Spot in West VillageAdd to myNY added
Two Boots Village is the perfect spot for anyone looking to mix things up with their pizza. Some locals’ favorites include the V for Vegan made with artichokes, red onions, shiitake mushrooms, sweet red pepper pesto, non-dairy cheese, or the Bayou Beast, which is a take on a Louisiana dish and made with spiced shrimp, crawfish, andouille, jalapeños, and mozzarella. Regardless of the pizza you choose, there are plenty of unique flavors sure to please every palette.
Unlike traditional New York Style Pizza, Two Boots focuses on creating unique cajun-Italian cooking, which is only enhanced by their eclectic atmosphere. Their restaurant is decorated with pieces from local artists, making it the perfect place to grab a slice and catch up with friends or family.
No matter what you order, you’re sure to be satisfied with the delicious food and excellent service at Two Boots Village.
Numero 28 PizzeriaItalian Restaurant in West VillageAdd to myNY added
If you’re looking for authentic Neapolitan pizza, look no further than Numero 28 Pizzeria. This spot is dedicated to serving up the best pizza in the city, and they definitely succeed. All of their pizzas are made with fresh ingredients and cooked in a wood-fired oven for an unbeatable flavor.
What makes Numero 28 so great is that you can taste the difference in their pizza. Not only do they have classic options like cheese and pepperoni, but they also have more unique flavors like mozzarella, mushrooms, and truffle oil or their five formaggi, made with five different kinds of cheese. Plus, if you’re feeling really hungry, they also offer other high-quality dining options like chicken parm, broccoli rabe, or baked ziti along with calzones, sandwiches, and salads.
If you’re looking for a fantastic pizza experience, be sure to check out Numero 28 Pizzeria. Not only do they have some of the best pizza in the city, but their unique flavors will leave you wanting more. Plus, their atmosphere is perfect for groups or date nights alike.
Artichoke Basille's Pizza on MacDougal StreetPizza Spot in West VillageAdd to myNY added
Artichoke Basille’s Pizza is an excellent spot for a late-night meal, as they’re open until four in the morning every day. This pizzeria offers New York City’s classic deep dish slices, available by the pie or by the slice to satisfy any cravings that may come up.
They offer eight different flavors of their famous pizza, including artichoke, crab, Margherita, vodka, state island, Sicilian, pepperoni, and meatballs.
You can either order individual slices or pies, depending on your preference. This simple yet delicious, classic New York-style pizza is the perfect way to end a night out with friends.
Percy's PizzaPizza Spot in Greenwich VillageAdd to myNY added
Percy’s Pizza is the perfect spot for a casual night out. Located directly on Bleecker street, they’re easily accessible no matter where you are in the village. Percy’s is best known for their large slices of pizza, which are perfect for satisfying any hunger craving.
While their classic cheese and pepperoni slices are always a hit, Percy’s also offers more unique flavors like their spicy eggplant pizza or the upside-down pizza. Plus, you can always create your own pizza with the toppings you desire and have it delivered right to your location, ensuring you can always enjoy their delicious food no matter what time it is.
Jr's Pizza and BrewPizza Spot in Greenwich VillageAdd to myNY added
Jr’s Pizza and Brew is the perfect place to go if you’re looking for a late-night slice of pizza and a cool beer to wash it down. Open until the early morning hours, this spot is excellent no matter what time of day it is. They offer more than just your average slices, too, giving customers options like salads, calzones, pasta, and sandwiches as well.
Their menu offers mostly pizzas with over 20 different types ranging from classics like cheese or pepperoni to unique flavors like their primavera pizza, including broccoli, spinach, tomatoes, and mozzarella cheese, or their Lasagna pizza filled with ground beef, mozzarella cheese, ricotta, and tomato sauce. Plus, not only are these pizzas delicious, but they’re huge! Their medium pizzas can feed up to three people, so there are plenty of leftovers at the end of the night.
If you’re looking for a simple, no-fuss pizza spot with delicious food and a great atmosphere, Jr’s Pizza and Brew is the place for you. Check out their great draft specials before heading out for a night on the town.
Spunto Thin Crust PizzaPizza Spot in West VillageAdd to myNY added
Spunto Thin Crust Pizza is a relaxed and casual pizza restaurant, perfect for a night out with family or friends. The thin-crust New York-style pizzas are cooked in a wood oven to give them the best flavor possible. Alongside their delicious pies, they also offer fresh salads as well as several different appetizers like hummus, garlic knots, Rotella, and bruschetta.
Their menu offers something that every customer can enjoy, from those who prefer meat lovers’ pizzas loaded with pepperoni and sausage to vegetarians looking for a pie filled with veggies. They even have vegan options! With all these choices, you’ll find it hard to decide between your favorite flavors, so take advantage of Spuntos create-your-own-pie option and choose all your favorite toppings.
No matter what kind of pizza is calling out to you, Spunto’s got the perfect pies for everyone! So if a delicious New York-style thin-crust pie sounds like something you’d enjoy, this spot in Bleecker street should be on your list of places to visit.
Pizza Pot PiesPizza Spot in Greenwich VillageAdd to myNY added
Pizza Pot Pie is the right place if you’re looking for a quick, cheap, and easy meal. With a wide variety of pizzas to choose from, as well as other menu items like sandwiches and salads, this spot is perfect for any time of day or night.
What makes Pizza Pot Pie so unique is their build your own pizza kit, allowing you to choose your own ingredients and have them all wrapped up in a personal-sized pie, perfect for a family get-together or a romantic date night.
Each pie is made with fresh ingredients cooked in a wood-fired oven for an unbeatable flavor. Not only do they have classic flavors like cheese and pepperoni, but they also feature vegan pizza, hemp pizza, white pizza, and fun appetizers like pepperoni rolls, chicken parm rolls, and garlic knots.
No matter what type of pizza you’re in the mood for, Pizza Pot Pie is sure to have something to satisfy your cravings. Stop by and see for yourself why this spot is one of the most popular pizzerias on Bleecker Street.
Now that you know about some of the best Bleecker street pizza spots in NYC be sure to check them out for yourself and experience why they’re so loved by locals and tourists alike! Whether you’re looking for a casual night out or a quick and easy meal, these spots are sure to please everyone’s palate.
What Is Greenwich Village?
Greenwich Village is a neighborhood in Lower Manhattan. It was once an artist’s haven, but now it’s home to NYU students and young professionals. The area is known for its nightlife, restaurants, and shops. Many people also visit Greenwich Village for its eclectic shops and small boutiques.
What Is Bleecker Street?
Bleecker Street is a busy street in New York’s West Village, Greenwich Village and NoHo neighborhoods. It has many restaurants, bars, and other businesses, including The Strand bookstore, the Apple Store, Starbucks, Duane Reade drugstores, Bed Bath & Beyond, and more. The street is often crowded with people, making it a great spot to watch people.
Bleecker Street has been deemed the “Pizza Capital of New York City.” This street is lined with some of the best pizzerias in the city, making it the perfect spot for pizza lovers looking for a good slice.
What Is New York Style Pizza?
New York-style pizza is a style of Neapolitan pizza from Italy. It’s made with a thin crust, which means it has a bread-like consistency but isn’t crispy like traditional Italian bread.
New York pizzas are baked in an oven that can reach incredibly high temperatures, giving the pies the perfect level of crispiness when they come out. A few of the most common types of pizzas, besides traditional sauce and cheese, includes:
- Meat lovers’ pizzas are loaded with toppings, including pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and meatballs. They’re the perfect type of pizza for anyone who loves lots of delicious meats on their pies!
- Vegetarian New York-style pizzas have various veggies as toppings instead of meats like other types of pizzas. This is the perfect option for anyone who wants a delicious pizza but doesn’t eat meat.
- Vegan New York-style pizzas are just like vegetarian pies, but they don’t have any cheese or other animal products on them. They’re perfect for anyone looking for a vegan-friendly pizza!
What Should I Consider Before Choosing A Pizza Joint?
When looking for a great pizza place to visit, you should consider a few things.
- What type of pizza do I want? There are many different types of pizzas, from classic New York-style pie to deep dish and even vegan pies. Consider what kind of pizza you’re in the mood for before choosing a spot.
- How crowded is the restaurant? If you’re looking for a quiet night out, choose a pizza place that isn’t too crowded. However, if you’re looking for a fun and lively atmosphere, go to a spot that’s known for its busyness.
- What are the hours of operation? Make sure the pizzeria you choose is open when you’re free to eat!
- What are the prices? Pizzas can range in price, so make sure you’re aware of how much each pie will cost. You don’t want to be surprised when the bill comes at the end of your meal.
You'll also love this:
I'm a true New York fan! Not only have I visited the city over 20 times but also have I spent several months here at a time. On my blog I show you the best and most beautiful spots of the city, so that you have a really good time! You can also find lots of insider tips in our New York travel guide. Also check out my hotel finder for New York!